Home         News         Staff            Directions           Bulletins-Announcements-Calendar          Weekly Worship Schedule          Site Index

An Organ History of Saint James in the Woods

Clintonville, Ohio

 

Timothy Smith

 

From early records, it appears the first organ in Saint James in the 1890’s was a one-manual reed organ, foot pumped and fitted with an imitation period pipe top. Following a substantial building enlargement in 1927, the parish undertook to purchase its first pipe organ. The new instrument was constructed in 1928 and dedicated May 26, 1929. The organ was located on the south wall of the chancel, which was arranged in an English collegiate manner at the time. Growth towards and beyond three hundred communicants of the parish in the 1940’s may have accounted for changes to the organ. A Quonset hut had been added to the south wall of the church, providing rehearsal and vesting space for the choir. In order to accommodate more seating in the choir stalls, the organ pipes were placed in a chamber inside the Quonset hut, with a tone opening cut through the south wall of the chancel. The console was placed behind the pulpit on the north wall, affording the organist a view of the singers for conducting. It was about this time the east window was covered by the installation of the reredos.

 

Though the 1929 organ may have had some musical integrity, its relocation to a remote spot proved less than satisfactory. Subsequent years of maintenance were carried out by the Durthaler Organ Company, but by the late 1960’s the organ was disappointing artistically and mechanically. At the inspiration of organist Susan Brattain, a capital campaign in 1969 raised funds for an entirely new organ, constructed in the Dutch High Renaissance style by John Brombaugh and Company of Middletown, Ohio. This new instrument of 572 pipes, the firm’s seventh organ, was free-standing in an oak case on the south wall of the chancel where the 1929 organ had originally stood. The Brombaugh was dedicated October 24, 1971 with a recital by Professor Arthur Carkeek of DePauw University.

 

Changes came to this organ as well. Two additional stops were installed later in the 1970’s, adding 168 pipes to the organ’s resources. In the 1980’s the collegiate chancel was altered, the reredos was moved away from the wall, and the Brombaugh was placed on the center axis of the nave behind the reredos. The choir sang from a variety of locations in the years that followed. Bruce Shull of Virginia (and later Joseph Zamberlain of Steubenville, Ohio) maintained the organ, rebuilding some of the pure tin pipes that were collapsing from metal fatigue.

 

Early in the life of the Brombaugh organ, the parish embraced a regular practice of the Sarum rite, offering masses in the Anglo-Catholic tradition, which has continued to the present. While the Brombaugh spoke with distinct clarity, its dynamic range and tonal palette were somewhat static for the dry acoustics of the church. Too, the organ’s design around mechanical key action eliminated space for singers, and as a result of liturgical changes to the sanctuary furnishings, it was difficult to maintain a consistent choral ensemble. In 2008, the Brombaugh was offered for sale with the intention of installing an organ that would afford extensive choir seating. The replacement organ was to provide a wide dynamic range with part of the pipework enclosed, and all families of pipe tone represented in an American classic design.

 

The west gallery provided an ideal place for pipes. Inaccessible to people and therefore unsuited for any future expansion, it allowed organ components to be placed on the center axis of the nave acoustics. A densely-walled Swell chamber was built to house about half of the organ, and fitted with shutters for dynamic control. It was also clear that some pipes would need to be located near the choir for consistent pitch and rhythm.

 

As a sidebar to American organ design, the precedent of “remote” organ pipes is a topic of some interest. The growing use of electricity in the mid 1880’s led to astonishing innovations in organ building. Console and pipes were no longer placed in immediate proximity. The era of special effects had dawned with “Echo” divisions of organs being installed far away from the balance of a church organ, sometimes in remote towers, basement chambers, etc. The repertoire for these devices was yet to be composed and therefore their classical usefulness was questionable; nevertheless, the technology was impressive. Often such installations were in rooms of dull acoustics, and the “surround-sound” created (about fifty years before stereo playback would appear) must have been magical. Notable East-coast Episcopal churches did use such technology in the twentieth century, both to overcome dry acoustics and to accommodate a large choral program trying to flourish within limited building square footage. In the 1920’s in New York City, Grace Church Lower Broadway had a large organ over the west door, operated from a console in the east end where there was a fine choir and a substantial chancel organ. At that same time, Trinity Church Boston (seating nearly 2000) installed a similar arrangement, allowing a distinguished choir to process and sing from the altar area, while the bulk of the organ was far away on the center axis of the church. Trinity Church New Haven (seating 1200) has a more pronounced example, where the entire rear gallery is given over to an organ case, and a small chancel organ assists singers in a chancel that is quite distant.

 

In May 2009 the Brombaugh was purchased by The Church of Saint Michael the Archangel in Leawood, Kansas. Dr. Kevin Vogt, music director of the parish coordinated the move with staff from Paul Fritts & Co. of Tacoma, Washington. St. Michael’s dedicated their new building, seating one thousand, in June of 2009. With minor modification to upperwork, the organ is free standing in the rear gallery and is easily seen and heard.

 

An instrument built in 1966 by The Reuter Organ Company of Lawrence, Kansas (opus 1545) was selected for relocation to the Saint James gallery. It was first installed in St. Mary’s Episcopal Church in Tacoma, Washington, and moved to Saint Joseph Cathedral in Columbus in 2004 as a practice organ for the cathedral choir room.  Additional pipes and components from a 1954 Reuter organ (opus 1049) built for Indiana University were acquired; three additional sets of pipes were built.  All the ranks were voiced into a cohesive new design particular to the intimate acoustics of the church. A new ensemble of pipes for the choir was provided, and a functional display of bass pipes created a new façade across the gallery. The spotted metal pipes described below are a standard American alloy, roughly half tin for brightness and half lead for resonance of tone.

 

The tonal scheme takes inspiration from mid-twentieth century American organs. Two principal choruses are complemented with 16’ manual stops to complete the tonal spectrum and limit strident overtone domination. Flute ranks are of wood construction, both stopped and open for tonal variety. Independent mutations (Nasard and Tierce) are available for solo color and adapt to French or German repertoire. The Trumpet stop is the first reed in the church. Installed in the Swell, it can be shaded dynamically and is invaluable for solo and ensemble combinations. The strings are boldly scaled and voiced for a broad, singing tone. Two tapered stops (the Choir Erzahler and the Great Gemshorn) create incisive pitch at a gentle volume. A dedicated Pedal rank lends breadth to the organ. Judicious duplexing of manual resources provides flexibility for accompaniment.

 

Timothy Smith, organist of the church, collaborated with David Melrose, president of Southfield Organ Builders of Springfield, Massachusetts in completing the organ of twenty ranks and 1100 pipes. Renovations Unlimited, Inc. of Grove City made needed revisions to the building to accommodate the new organ. Thirty-nine volunteers, parishioners and friends of Saint James, spent many hours in the spring and summer of 2009 helping in the organ’s preparation: Martha, Meredeth, Carolyn, Dana, Michael Beckett; Joe, Wendy, Eric Panzner; Eric Reasoner; Alexander and Andrew Martin; Mike and Diana McCullough; Todd Colquitt; Douglas Argue; Elise Feyerherm; Andrea Plant; Robert Hoon; Lynn Carter-Edmands; Isabel and Alan Brown; Jean and Betty Brown; Helen and Tim Smith; William Foster; Nathan and Morgan Rodgers; Jonah Kraut; Dusty Black; Barbara Hunt; Chase Maffe; Rick Warren; Jason Prati; Cindy Kollmer; Mike Herzog; Stephen Sollars; Mark Tegtmeier; James Train.

 

We are grateful also to Franklin Art Glass for restoring the east window, first installed in 1919, to Richard Sayre and Carolyn Beckett for photography, and to Jeanne Haber and David Homan for graphic design assistance.

 

The Reuter-Southfield Organ

2009 – 1215 pipes – 20 ranks – 3 ½” windpressure

 

Great

16             Gemshorn                                61 pipes                    24 zinc, 37 tapered 50% tin

8               Principal                                    61 pipes                    17 zinc in façade, 44 50% tin

8               Traverse Flute                         49 pipes   mahogany, harmonic

4 Octave 61 pipes 5 zinc in façade, 56 50% tin

III Mixture 183 pipes

8 Trumpet Swell

8 Choir Erzahler 61 pipes 14 zinc, 47 tapered 50% tin

8 Choir Prestant 37 pipes

4 Choir Prestant 12 pipes

8 Gedackt Swell

8 Gamba Celeste Swell

8 Gamba Swell

4 Gedackt Swell

Swell to Great

 

Swell

16 Gedackt 12 pipes stopped pine, behind Swell box

8 Geigen 61 pipes 12 zinc, 49 50 % tin

8 Gedackt 61 pipes stopped mahogany

8 Gamba 61 pipes 10 zinc, 51 50% tin

8 Celeste TC 49 pipes 3 zinc, 46 50% tin

4 Geigen 12 pipes

4 Gedackt 12 pipes

2 2/3 Nasard GG 49 pipes narrow mouth 50% tin

2 Octave 24 pipes 50% tin

1 3/5 Tierce GG 49 pipes narrow mouth 50% tin

III Mixture 183 pipes

16 Trumpet 12 pipes half-length bass

8 Trumpet 61 pipes 56 reeds

Tremolo pneumatic

  

Pedal

32 Subbass #1-12 plays Gedackt as Quint

16 Bourdon 32 pipes mahogany, 24 in façade

16 Gedeckt Swell

16 Gemshorn Great

8 Bourdon 12 pipes

8 Geigen Swell

8 Gedackt Swell

4 Geigen Swell

16 Trumpet Swell

Great to Pedal

Swell to Pedal

© 2000 - 2010 St. James Episcopal Church

St. James Episcopal Church

3400 Calumet Street

Columbus, Ohio  43214-4106

614.262.2360

 

NOTE:  This webpage is best viewed at a setting of 1024 X 768 pixels

Contact the Webmaster with any questions or comments (please place St. James in the subject line).